Nuclear war
1 in 1,000 · existential catastrophe within 100 years
A large exchange of strikes would, besides the explosions, lift soot into the stratosphere and cause a nuclear winter lasting years.
Estimates
| existential catastrophe within 100 yearsToby Ord: The Precipice (2020), table 6.1, p. 167 | 0.1% |
| Expert survey 2008 · extinction by 2100Sandberg, Bostrom: Global Catastrophic Risks Survey, FHI Technical Report 2008/1 | 1% |
Matches two independent citations of the table. Not checked in the book itself. Checked against: 80,000 Hours: The case for reducing existential risks, 80,000 Hours podcast with Toby Ord (2020).
Numbers from different sources measure different things (existential catastrophe within 100 years, extinction by 2100, upper bound). Each states what it measures.
What is being done
Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT)
In force since 1970, joined by 191 states. It aims to prevent the spread of nuclear weapons, promote peaceful use of nuclear energy and work towards disarmament.
UNODA: Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear WeaponsTreaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons
In force since 22 January 2021, it bans the states that have joined it from developing, testing, producing, stockpiling and using nuclear weapons.
UN Treaty Collection: Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons
How it could unfold
Nuclear explosion: Novaya Zemlya (Tsar Bomba)
Tsar Bomba · 30 October 1961 · Wikipedia: Tsar Bomba
- Phase 1 · 11:32 Moscow time
Explosion
The bomb exploded about 4 km above the Novaya Zemlya archipelago. The fireball was about 8 km at its widest and could be seen from almost 1,000 km.
Source: Wikipedia: Tsar Bomba - Phase 2 · minutes
Mushroom cloud
The cloud rose to about 67 km and its base was 40 km wide. It was still observed from 800 km away.
Source: Wikipedia: Tsar Bomba - Phase 3 · seconds to minutes
Heat and destruction
All buildings in the settlement of Severny, 55 km from the explosion, were destroyed. The heat could have caused third-degree burns up to 100 km away and the thermal pulse was felt as far as 270 km.
Source: Wikipedia: Tsar Bomba - Phase 4 · first orbit 36 hours 27 minutes
A shock wave around the Earth
Window panes partly broke as far as 900 km away. The shock wave circled the Earth three times.
Source: Wikipedia: Tsar Bomba
Nuclear attack on a city: Hiroshima
Little Boy · 6 August 1945 · Wikipedia: Little Boy
- Phase 1 · 8:15 a.m.
Explosion over the city
The Little Boy bomb exploded over Hiroshima with an energy of about 15 kilotons of TNT. The blast radius was about 1.3 km. On the globe the zone is smaller than a single point; the scale in the panel shows the real proportions.
Source: Wikipedia: Little Boy - Phase 2 · the following months
Victims
Within two to four months of the explosion, 90,000 to 166,000 people died in Hiroshima. The 1961 Tsar Bomba was more than three thousand times more powerful.
Source: Radiation Effects Research Foundation: How many people died as a result of the atomic bombings? (FAQ)
Nuclear winter: nuclear war
Regional war India – Pakistan · Toon et al. (2019) model · Toon et al.: Rapidly expanding nuclear arsenals in Pakistan and India portend regional and global catastrophe, Science Advances 5 (2019)
Text applies to: Regional war India – Pakistan. Other options: Global nuclear war.
- Phase 1 · hours
Strikes on cities
India uses 100 and Pakistan 150 strategic weapons against cities. Direct deaths: 50 to 125 million people. The point on the globe is only the centre of view, not the site of an explosion.
Source: Toon et al.: Rapidly expanding nuclear arsenals in Pakistan and India portend regional and global catastrophe, Science Advances 5 (2019), Wikipedia: Nuclear winter (Robock et al. 2007 model and the 2018 Los Alamos study) - Phase 2 · days to weeks
Fires and soot
Burning cities lift 16 to 36 million tonnes of black soot into the stratosphere. The wind spreads it around the Earth; the direction on the globe is illustrative.
Source: Toon et al.: Rapidly expanding nuclear arsenals in Pakistan and India portend regional and global catastrophe, Science Advances 5 (2019), Wikipedia: Nuclear winter (Robock et al. 2007 model and the 2018 Los Alamos study) - Phase 3 · months to years
A veil of soot
20 to 35% less sunlight reaches the surface. Precipitation falls by 15 to 30%.
Source: Toon et al.: Rapidly expanding nuclear arsenals in Pakistan and India portend regional and global catastrophe, Science Advances 5 (2019), Robock, Oman, Stenchikov: Nuclear winter revisited with a modern climate model and current nuclear arsenals, J. Geophys. Res. 2007 - Phase 4 · years
Nuclear winter
The Earth's surface cools by 2 to 5 °C on average. Plant productivity falls by 15 to 30% on land and by 5 to 15% in the oceans.
Source: Toon et al.: Rapidly expanding nuclear arsenals in Pakistan and India portend regional and global catastrophe, Science Advances 5 (2019), Robock, Oman, Stenchikov: Nuclear winter revisited with a modern climate model and current nuclear arsenals, J. Geophys. Res. 2007 - Phase 5 · years to a decade
Hunger and uncertainty
Recovery takes more than 10 years. According to a further study (Xia et al. 2022), even the smallest India–Pakistan war would cut global calorie production by 7% within five years.
Source: Xia et al.: Global food insecurity and famine from reduced crop yields due to climate disruption caused by nuclear war soot injection, Nature Food 2022 (Rutgers press release), Wikipedia: Nuclear winter (Robock et al. 2007 model and the 2018 Los Alamos study)
Close calls
- 27 Oct 1962
Submarine B-59
During the Cuban Missile Crisis, US ships dropped depth charges near the Soviet submarine B-59. The captain thought war had broken out and wanted to launch a nuclear torpedo. The launch required the consent of three officers. Vasily Arkhipov refused and persuaded the captain to surface and await orders.
Wikipedia: Vasily Arkhipov - 26 Sep 1983
Stanislav Petrov's false alarm
The Soviet early-warning system Oko reported the launch of a US intercontinental missile followed by four more. The duty officer Stanislav Petrov waited for confirmation instead of reporting it immediately. It was a false alarm caused by sunlight on high-altitude clouds. The public only learned about it in 1998.
Wikipedia: 1983 Soviet nuclear false alarm incident - 25 Jan 1995
The Norwegian research rocket
Scientists launched a Black Brant XII rocket from Norway to study the aurora. Russian nuclear forces feared an attack and were on alert for about eight minutes; President Yeltsin activated the nuclear briefcase for the first time. Russia had been notified in advance, but the message never reached the military from the foreign ministry.
Wikipedia: Norwegian rocket incident
All threats
- Unaligned AI10%
- Nanotechnology weapons5%
- Wars4%
- Engineered pandemic3.3%
- Unforeseen risks3.3%
- Other human-made risks2%
- Nanotechnology accident0.5%
- Nuclear war0.1%
- Climate change0.1%
- Other environmental damage0.1%
- Nuclear terrorism0.03%
- Supervolcano0.01%
- Natural pandemic0.01%
- Asteroid or comet0.0001%
- Vacuum decay and other cosmic catastrophes< 0.00001%
- Stellar explosion0.0000001%
- Solar superstormbez odhadu